The short answer: if you cover long distances, tow, or can't charge at home, a well-kept petrol Macan S or GTS is still the easier car to live with. If you can charge at home and most of your driving is under 200 miles a day, the Macan Electric is quicker, quieter and - for company car drivers - far cheaper to run. Here's how I'd decide.
Why this question matters now
Porsche stopped selling the petrol Macan new in Europe during 2024, citing new vehicle cybersecurity regulations, and the second-generation Macan is electric. That means every petrol Macan you can buy in the UK today is a used car - and the supply will only shrink. At the same time, the first Macan Electrics are now arriving on the used market.
The two cars at a glance
| Petrol Macan (95B, 2014-2024) | Macan Electric (2024 on) | |
|---|---|---|
| Engines | 2.0 four-cylinder, 2.9/3.0 V6 (S, GTS), Turbo | Single or twin electric motors (Macan, 4, 4S, Turbo) |
| Platform | Shared with the Audi Q5 family | PPE platform, 800-volt electrics |
| Refuelling | Five minutes, anywhere | Up to 270kW DC rapid charging; home charging is the key |
| Towing | Up to 2,400kg on most versions | Check the individual model - many versions rated up to 2,000kg |
| Character | Engaging, sounds like a sports car | Instant torque, very refined, heavier |
| Used supply | Plentiful but finite | Growing as early cars come off lease |
Figures from Porsche published specifications. Always check the exact car's V5C, build sheet and towing rating.
Running costs in the UK
Since 1 April 2025, electric cars pay Vehicle Excise Duty. Any car - petrol or electric - with a list price over £40,000 also pays the expensive car supplement for five years from its second year of tax. Almost every Macan exceeds that threshold, so tax is no longer a clear win for the electric car if you're a private buyer.
Company car drivers are a different story. Benefit-in-kind on electric cars is 3% in 2025/26, rising to 4% in 2026/27 and 5% in 2027/28. A petrol Macan sits in the top band. If you're buying through a business, the Electric usually wins by a wide margin.
What I check on a used petrol Macan
- PDK servicing - fluid changes at the right intervals, and a smooth, crisp gearbox from cold.
- Air suspension (if fitted) - the car should sit level overnight.
- Brake discs and pads - Macans are heavy and eat brakes; budget accordingly.
- Turbo V6 cars - look for coolant leaks around the hot-V and an untroubled warm idle.
- A complete service record. The Macan rewards owners who didn't skip a year.
What I check on a used Macan Electric
- A battery health report (state of health) from a Porsche Centre or a capable specialist.
- The remaining manufacturer and high-voltage battery warranty, and that recalls and software updates are done.
- Charging history if available - a car rapid-charged every day is worth asking about.
- Options: heat pump, rear-axle steering and the larger wheels all change how the car lives day to day.
So which should you buy?
| If you... | I'd lean towards |
|---|---|
| Do lots of motorway miles or tow a horsebox or caravan | Petrol Macan S or GTS |
| Can charge at home and mostly drive locally | Macan Electric |
| Buy through a company | Macan Electric |
| Want the most driver-focused Macan | Petrol GTS |
| Plan to keep the car ten years | A low-mileage petrol car with full history, or an Electric with a strong battery report |
Whichever way you go, the individual car matters more than the badge. My pre-purchase inspection guide covers what a proper check looks like, and our current 2911 Approved stock is updated as cars arrive. If you'd like me to find a specific Macan, that's exactly what my sourcing service is for.
Sources
- Porsche Newsroom - the new all-electric Macan
- GOV.UK - Vehicle tax rate tables (from April 2025)
- GOV.UK - Expensive car supplement and electric car tax changes
- GOV.UK - Company car benefit-in-kind appropriate percentages
Quick answers
Is the petrol Porsche Macan still sold new in the UK?
No. Porsche stopped selling the petrol Macan new in Europe during 2024, citing new cybersecurity regulations. Every petrol Macan available in the UK today is a used car.
Should I buy a petrol or electric Porsche Macan?
A petrol Macan S or GTS suits high-mileage drivers, towing and owners without home charging. The Macan Electric suits drivers who can charge at home and company car buyers, thanks to low benefit-in-kind rates.
Do electric Porsches pay road tax in the UK?
Yes. Since 1 April 2025 electric cars pay Vehicle Excise Duty, and cars with a list price over £40,000 also pay the expensive car supplement for five years from the second year of tax.
What should I check on a used Macan Electric?
Ask for a battery state-of-health report, confirm the remaining warranty and battery warranty, check recalls and software updates are complete, and review the specification such as heat pump and rear-axle steering.
What should I check on a used petrol Macan?
Check the PDK servicing history, air suspension (if fitted), brake wear, coolant leaks on V6 turbo engines and a complete service record.




